5 Non–Supper Clubs to Check Out the Next Time You’re in Minocqua

Not every night in the Northwoods needs to revolve around a traditional supper club. While those are a staple of the area, part of what makes Minocqua such a great destination is the variety of more casual, modern, and local-favorite spots that still capture that laid-back, welcoming Northwoods feel.

Whether you’re coming off the lake, heading out for the night, or just looking for something quick and easy without sacrificing quality, these five non–supper club restaurants are worth working into your plans.

Heart II

A go-to for something casual, Heart II is known for its relaxed atmosphere and consistently good comfort food. It’s the kind of place you can walk into after a long day outside and immediately feel settled in.

Their Cobb salad has built a bit of a reputation—and for good reason. It’s generous enough to share and loaded in a way that actually makes it worth ordering. And if you’re leaning more indulgent, the homemade bacon mac and cheese pizza is one of those unexpected menu items that ends up being a highlight of the trip.

The Nest (formerly Preuss’s Pub)

A true Northwoods staple with a refreshed identity, The Nest carries over everything people loved about Preuss’s Pub—classic bar atmosphere, strong burgers, and a place where locals actually hang out.

It’s simple in the best way. Sirloin burgers, cold drinks, and a no-frills environment that doesn’t try too hard. Add in occasional live music and rotating specials like their Dill Pickle Pizza, and it becomes an easy stop whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or staying a while.

Five1 Bar & Grill

If you’re looking for something with a little more energy, Five1 hits that balance between casual dinner spot and social hangout. It’s a great option for groups, especially when not everyone wants the same thing.

The menu covers all the bases, but their seafood stands out—especially the Canadian walleye. And if you’re in town on a Friday, their perch fry is one of those meals that feels like a Northwoods tradition, even outside of a supper club setting.

Bad Bones BBQ

When you’re in the mood for something hearty, Bad Bones BBQ delivers every time. This is where you go when you want bold flavors, generous portions, and food that feels a little more indulgent after a day outside. Dine in or order out!

The Madtown Max is a standout for a reason, and the Carolina fries are hard to pass up. What really sets it apart is the variety of house-made sauces—there’s enough range to customize your meal every time, which is probably why it ends up on repeat for a lot of visitors.

The Grill

Sometimes you just want something easy, reliable, and good—and The Grill fits that role perfectly. It’s a solid choice any day but great place to stop on your way in and out of town. With a large parking lot and outdoor seating, it's the perfect stop for those who tow and want to stretch their legs!

The menu is well-rounded and approachable, but don’t overlook the sides. They tend to be just as memorable as the main dishes, and in some cases, might even steal the spotlight.

Minocqua’s food scene goes far beyond the traditional supper club. While those experiences are worth having, mixing in more casual, local spots like these gives you a better feel for the area—and often ends up being where some of the best, most relaxed moments of your trip happen.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite between lake days or settling in for an easy night out, these restaurants offer a different side of the Northwoods that’s just as worth experiencing.

Interested in Supper Clubs? Check out our new Pod Cast Episode with Schellie's Sconnie Shenanigans!